The Best Reddit Post Comment Of All Time What Makes A Post Legendary
Have you ever stumbled upon a Reddit thread that completely blew your mind? A comment so witty, so insightful, or so hilarious that it stuck with you long after you closed the tab? Reddit, the self-proclaimed "front page of the internet," is a treasure trove of user-generated content, and within its vast expanse lie some truly legendary posts and comments. But what exactly makes a Reddit post the best? Is it the sheer number of upvotes, the profound impact it had on the community, or the pure comedic genius it embodies? Let's dive into the fascinating world of Reddit and explore some contenders for the title of the best Reddit post/comment of all time.
The Quest for the Best: Defining "Best" on Reddit
Before we can crown a champion, we need to define what makes a Reddit post truly exceptional. Is it simply popularity? While upvotes and awards are certainly indicators of a post's resonance, they don't tell the whole story. A post could be incredibly popular for a fleeting moment due to a trending topic, but true legendary status requires something more enduring. We're talking about posts that spark meaningful conversations, offer unique perspectives, or simply make us laugh until our sides hurt. Think about the posts that you've shared with friends, the ones you keep coming back to, and the ones that have genuinely impacted your understanding of the world. These are the posts that have the potential to be considered the "best." So, beyond the numbers, we need to consider factors like originality, humor, insightfulness, impact, and the ability to stand the test of time. A truly great Reddit post should be more than just a fleeting viral sensation; it should be a piece of internet history. We need to look beyond the surface and delve into the heart of what makes a Reddit community thrive: the shared experiences, the witty banter, and the genuine human connection.
To further refine our search, let's consider some specific categories of Reddit posts that often reach legendary status:
- The Hilarious: Reddit is a breeding ground for humor, and some comments and posts are so brilliantly funny that they become instant classics. These are the ones that get quoted, memed, and referenced for years to come.
- The Heartwarming: Amidst the memes and cynicism, Reddit also has a soft side. Posts about acts of kindness, personal triumphs, and heartwarming stories often resonate deeply with the community.
- The Insightful: Reddit is home to countless experts and knowledgeable individuals who share their wisdom on a wide range of topics. Insightful posts that offer unique perspectives or break down complex subjects can be incredibly valuable.
- The Shocking: Sometimes, a Reddit post goes viral because it reveals a shocking truth, exposes a scandal, or shares an unbelievable personal experience. These posts often spark intense debate and discussion.
- The Community-Driven: Some of the best Reddit posts are those that involve the community in a creative way, such as collaborative storytelling threads or interactive games.
With these criteria in mind, let's explore some of the contenders for the title of the best Reddit post/comment of all time.
Contenders for the Crown: Iconic Reddit Moments
Now, let's get to the fun part: exploring some of the most memorable and highly regarded Reddit posts and comments. It's impossible to create a definitive list, as "best" is subjective and depends on individual tastes. However, there are certain posts that have achieved widespread recognition and are frequently cited as examples of Reddit at its finest. Let's take a look at a few examples, spanning different categories and subreddits:
1. The Swamps of Dagobah
This infamous post from the subreddit /r/AskReddit is a prime example of Reddit's ability to delve into the bizarre and disturbing. The question posed was, "What is the worst thing you have ever smelled?" and the top-voted response detailed a truly horrific (and likely fictional) experience involving a forgotten apartment and a biological disaster. The graphic nature of the story made it both repulsive and strangely captivating, and it has become a legendary tale within the Reddit community. The impact of this post lies in its ability to shock and disturb, while simultaneously showcasing the power of storytelling and the willingness of Redditors to share even the most unsettling experiences. The post's enduring legacy is a testament to its ability to evoke a strong emotional response, even if that response is one of disgust and horror. It's a reminder that Reddit is a place where the boundaries of acceptable content are often pushed, and where the unexpected can always be found lurking in the shadows.
2. The Two Wolves Story
This heartwarming story, often shared in various subreddits, tells the tale of an old Cherokee man teaching his grandson about the battle between two wolves that lives inside each of us: one good and one evil. The grandson asks which wolf will win, and the grandfather replies, "The one you feed." This simple yet powerful message about the importance of nurturing positive qualities has resonated with countless Redditors. The beauty of this post lies in its profound message conveyed through a concise and easily digestible narrative. It speaks to the universal human struggle between good and evil and offers a simple yet effective framework for making positive choices. The story's enduring popularity is a testament to its ability to inspire hope and promote introspection. It's a reminder that even in the face of adversity, we have the power to choose the path we take and to shape our own destinies.
3. The Coconut Story
Another notorious entry from /r/AskReddit, this post involves a man recounting a highly inappropriate (and likely fictional) story involving a coconut. Similar to the Swamps of Dagobah, the Coconut Story is known for its graphic nature and shocking content. While highly disturbing, it has also become a dark comedy classic within the Reddit community. The shock value of this story is undeniable, and it's a prime example of Reddit's willingness to embrace the taboo. The story's notoriety stems from its ability to push the boundaries of acceptable content and to provoke a strong reaction, whether it be laughter, disgust, or a combination of both. While not for the faint of heart, the Coconut Story has earned its place in Reddit lore as a testament to the platform's willingness to explore the darker corners of human imagination.
4. EA's Downvoted Comment
This comment from Electronic Arts (EA) on /r/StarWarsBattlefront holds the Guinness World Record for the most downvoted comment in Reddit history. The comment was a defense of EA's decision to include loot boxes in the game, and Redditors responded with overwhelming disapproval. This event became a symbol of the tension between game developers and players over monetization practices. The significance of this comment lies in its representation of the power of the Reddit community to hold corporations accountable. The sheer volume of downvotes served as a resounding message to EA and other game developers that predatory monetization practices are not acceptable. The event sparked a broader conversation about the ethics of loot boxes and their impact on the gaming industry, and it remains a powerful example of Reddit's ability to influence corporate behavior.
