Is A Coco Sequel A Good Idea? Pixar's Potential Misstep

Kenji Nakamura

4 min read

Post on May 29, 2025

4.8

Share

The Success of Coco: A High Bar to Clear

Coco's success was undeniable. Its impact resonates far beyond simple box office numbers. Let's examine its achievements:

• Coco box office: The film grossed over $800 million worldwide, solidifying its place as a major cinematic success.
• Critical acclaim: Coco received widespread critical acclaim, culminating in an Academy Award for Best Animated Feature. This recognition cemented its status as a high-quality animated film.
• Cultural impact: The film's sensitive and respectful portrayal of Dia de los Muertos garnered significant praise, raising awareness and appreciation for Mexican traditions globally. It showcased the beauty and richness of the culture, making it accessible to a wider audience.
• Dia de los Muertos representation: The authentic and heartfelt depiction of Dia de los Muertos was a key element of Coco's success, making it a landmark representation of Mexican culture in animation.

The original film's success sets an incredibly high bar for any potential sequel. Matching, let alone surpassing, its artistic and cultural achievements will be a monumental task for even a studio as accomplished as Pixar. A Coco 2 would need to bring something truly unique to the table.

Potential Storylines and Their Risks

The challenge of creating a Coco sequel lies in crafting a compelling narrative that complements, rather than diminishes, the original. Several potential storylines exist, each with its own set of risks:

• Miguel's story: Continuing Miguel's story risks diluting the original's emotional impact. His journey of self-discovery was complete, and revisiting it could feel forced or unnecessary.
• Family legacy: Exploring the family legacy further could offer a compelling angle, but it needs to present new challenges and discoveries. Simply rehashing past conflicts would fall flat.
• New characters: Introducing new characters might not resonate with audiences as deeply as the original's beloved cast. A new protagonist would require a unique journey to match Miguel's emotional resonance.
• Dia de los Muertos themes: While exploring different aspects of Dia de los Muertos traditions could enrich the narrative, it's crucial to maintain authenticity and avoid simplistic tropes.
• Sequel story ideas: Any new narrative must justify its existence. It must offer something new and equally captivating to avoid being seen as a mere cash grab.

Finding a compelling narrative that complements the original without feeling forced or unnecessary is a significant challenge. A Coco sequel needs a fresh, imaginative story, not just a re-tread of familiar ground.

The Risk of Cultural Appropriation

A significant concern surrounding a Coco sequel is the potential for cultural appropriation. Pixar's handling of Mexican culture and Dia de los Muertos traditions in the original film was praised for its sensitivity and respect. However, any sequel must continue this commitment to authenticity. Failing to do so could result in severe criticism and backlash. The story needs to be developed in consultation with Mexican cultural experts to ensure accurate and respectful representation. Any misstep in this area could irrevocably damage the franchise and Pixar's reputation.

The Business Case for a Coco Sequel

Despite the artistic risks, the business case for a Coco sequel is strong. The potential financial gains are substantial:

• Box office potential: The original film's success virtually guarantees significant box office revenue for a sequel.
• Merchandising opportunities: The film's popularity opens doors to extensive merchandising opportunities, creating additional revenue streams.
• Franchise potential: A successful sequel could establish a lucrative Coco franchise with potential for future films or spin-offs, extending its lifespan and profitability.

While the creative challenges are significant, the potential financial returns are undeniable. For Disney, this commercial appeal might outweigh the artistic concerns.

Conclusion:

The decision to create a Coco sequel is fraught with complexities. The balance between artistic integrity and commercial potential is precarious. While the original Coco movie’s success makes a sequel tempting from a business standpoint, the risk of falling short of its artistic and cultural achievements, and even causing offense through misrepresentation, is considerable. Pixar must prioritize a compelling, respectful narrative that honors the original's legacy and avoids cultural appropriation. The success of a Coco sequel hinges on this delicate balance. Will a Coco sequel truly honor the original's spirit, or will it prove to be a missed opportunity? We'd love to hear your thoughts on a potential Coco sequel in the comments below!