New York City FC Vs Toronto FC: Player Ratings Compared

Kenji Nakamura

4 min read

Post on May 15, 2025

4.7

Share

Goalkeeper Performance Comparison

NYCFC Goalkeeper Analysis

NYCFC's goalkeeper has been a crucial part of their recent success. Let's examine the numbers:

• Number of saves in recent matches: Averaging 4 saves per game over the last five matches.
• Clean sheet percentage: A solid 40% clean sheet rate in recent games.
• Goals conceded per game average: Conceding an average of 1.2 goals per game.
• Overall rating from reputable sources: WhoScored gives him an average rating of 7.2 over the last five matches.

Toronto FC Goalkeeper Analysis

Toronto FC's goalkeeper has faced a tougher run of fixtures. Here's a look at his statistics:

• Number of saves in recent matches: Averaging 3.5 saves per game.
• Clean sheet percentage: A lower 30% clean sheet rate.
• Goals conceded per game average: Conceding an average of 1.5 goals per game.
• Overall rating from reputable sources: WhoScored rates him at 6.8 over the same period.

Direct Comparison

While both goalkeepers have performed admirably, NYCFC's goalkeeper edges out his Toronto FC counterpart in terms of clean sheets and overall rating, suggesting slightly stronger performance based on available data.

Defensive Line Analysis (NYCFC vs Toronto FC)

NYCFC Defensive Performance

NYCFC's defense has been relatively robust in recent games:

• Tackles won per game: Averaging 12 tackles won per game.
• Interceptions per game: Recording an average of 8 interceptions per game.
• Individual player ratings (e.g., from WhoScored, ESPN): Key defenders consistently receive ratings above 7.0 from WhoScored.

Toronto FC Defensive Performance

Toronto's defense has shown vulnerability in recent matches:

• Tackles won per game: Averaging 10 tackles per game.
• Interceptions per game: Recording an average of 6 interceptions per game.
• Individual player ratings (e.g., from WhoScored, ESPN): Key defenders have seen ratings fluctuate, with some falling below the 7.0 mark.

Comparative Analysis

NYCFC's defensive line shows more consistency and higher ratings, suggesting a more reliable backline compared to Toronto FC.

Midfield Battle: NYCFC vs Toronto FC

NYCFC Midfielders' Ratings

NYCFC's midfield has been instrumental in controlling possession and dictating the tempo:

• High pass completion rates, averaging above 85%.
• Key passes per game contribute significantly to attacking opportunities.
• Individual player ratings consistently above 7.0 from major rating sites.

Toronto FC Midfielders' Ratings

Toronto FC's midfield has struggled to maintain control in many recent games:

• Lower pass completion percentages, averaging around 78%.
• Fewer key passes created compared to NYCFC's midfielders.
• Individual ratings generally lower than their NYCFC counterparts.

Midfield Dominance

NYCFC demonstrates clear midfield dominance based on these statistics and ratings. Their superior possession and creative playmaking are reflected in the higher individual and team ratings.

Attacking Prowess: A Comparison of NYCFC and Toronto FC Forwards

NYCFC Forward Line Analysis

NYCFC's forwards have consistently found the back of the net:

• Goals scored: Averaging 1.8 goals per game from their forward line.
• Assists: Significant number of assists indicating effective link-up play.
• Shots on target: High shot accuracy, maximizing goal-scoring opportunities.
• Individual ratings: High individual ratings reflecting consistently strong performances.

Toronto FC Forward Line Analysis

Toronto FC's forwards have experienced a dip in form:

• Goals scored: Averaging 1.2 goals per game.
• Assists: Fewer assists reflecting less effective attacking combinations.
• Shots on target: Lower shot accuracy, indicating less clinical finishing.
• Individual ratings: Lower individual ratings indicating a less effective attacking performance.

Goal Scoring Threat

NYCFC's forward line poses a more significant goal-scoring threat based on their superior goal output, assist numbers, and individual player ratings.

Conclusion

This New York City FC vs Toronto FC player ratings comparison reveals a clear advantage for NYCFC across multiple facets of the game. Their goalkeeping, defense, midfield control, and attacking prowess all demonstrate superior performance according to available ratings data. While Toronto FC has shown flashes of brilliance, NYCFC's consistency and higher individual player ratings suggest a more well-rounded and currently stronger team.

Key Takeaways: NYCFC demonstrates a stronger overall team performance based on player ratings across all areas of the pitch. Their midfield control and clinical finishing are key differentiators.

What are your thoughts on this New York City FC vs Toronto FC player ratings comparison? Share your opinions and predictions for their upcoming matches in the comments below!