Steelers Should Trade For This NFC Quarterback?

Kenji Nakamura

3 min read

Post on May 22, 2025

4.6

Share

Dak Prescott's Strengths and Fit with the Steelers

Passing Prowess

Dak Prescott boasts impressive passing statistics. His ability to read defenses and make accurate throws downfield is undeniable.

• Impressive Performances: Prescott has consistently delivered high-yardage games, often exceeding 300 passing yards, demonstrating his capability to lead high-scoring drives. His performance in the 2022 season against the New York Giants is a prime example.
• Alignment with Steelers' Scheme: Prescott's strong arm and accuracy fit well with the Steelers' offensive scheme, which prioritizes both short and deep passes. His ability to extend plays with his mobility would also be a significant asset. He could elevate the performance of receivers like Diontae Johnson and George Pickens.

Leadership Qualities and Team Chemistry

Prescott is known for his leadership both on and off the field. His positive attitude and team-first mentality could inject new energy into the Steelers' locker room.

• Motivational Leadership: Prescott is frequently cited as a leader by his teammates, actively mentoring younger players and fostering a supportive team environment.
• Potential Steelers Synergy: Prescott's experience and leadership could positively influence the younger players on the Steelers' roster, potentially creating a stronger team dynamic and boosting morale.

Durability and Injury History

While Prescott has experienced some injuries, his overall durability is relatively strong compared to other quarterbacks in the league.

• Significant Injuries: His most notable injury was a compound fracture and dislocation of his ankle in 2020, but he has since recovered well.
• Injury Comparison: Compared to other quarterbacks with similar playing styles, Prescott's injury history doesn't stand out as unusually problematic.

Trade Feasibility and Potential Cost

Assessing the Trade Package

Acquiring Dak Prescott would require a substantial trade package, potentially involving multiple high draft picks and possibly a young, promising player.

• Realistic Trade Scenarios: The Steelers could offer a combination of first and second-round picks, along with a player like Alex Highsmith or Devin Bush, to make a competitive offer.
• Assets the Steelers Could Offer: The Steelers have a strong draft position, and trading down to accumulate more picks could increase their leverage in negotiations.

Salary Cap Implications

Prescott's contract would significantly impact the Steelers' salary cap.

• Contract Restructuring: The Steelers might need to restructure existing contracts or release some players to accommodate Prescott's salary.
• Long-Term Financial Implications: A long-term contract extension for Prescott would necessitate careful financial planning, but the potential payoff in terms of playoff success could outweigh the financial risk.

Alternative Options and Comparisons

The Steelers could explore other quarterback options, including free agency and the draft. However, a trade for Prescott presents a compelling alternative.

• Free Agency Limitations: Free agency might offer limited options at the quarterback position, especially if the top tier signs early.
• Draft Risks: Drafting a quarterback carries significant risk; success isn't guaranteed. Prescott offers a proven commodity and immediate impact.

Conclusion: Making the Case for a Steelers Trade for an NFC Quarterback

Trading for Dak Prescott presents a viable and potentially game-changing move for the Pittsburgh Steelers. His passing prowess, leadership skills, and relative durability directly address the Steelers' current quarterback deficiencies. While the trade cost and salary cap implications are significant, the potential reward—a substantial boost in playoff contention—makes it a worthwhile gamble. Counterarguments often center on the cost of the trade; however, the potential for immediate playoff contention and sustained success outweighs the price. Do you think the Steelers should pull the trigger on a trade for this NFC quarterback? Let us know in the comments below!